Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

snap, crackle and pop
watchnerd
senior member
senior member
Posts: 531
Joined: 11 May 2014 19:09
Location: Seattle

Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by watchnerd » 04 Jun 2018 04:14

The new TK series of Jelco tonearms (TK-950, TK-850) use knife-edge bearings, a departure from the ball bearings used in the SA-750 and its replacement, the TS-550.

As an owner of a Jelco SA-750D, I'm curious:

What are the pros & cons of knife edge bearing tonearms?

Spinner45
long player
long player
United States of America
Posts: 2303
Joined: 01 Mar 2017 18:21

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by Spinner45 » 04 Jun 2018 04:57

watchnerd wrote:The new TK series of Jelco tonearms (TK-950, TK-850) use knife-edge bearings, a departure from the ball bearings used in the SA-750 and its replacement, the TS-550.

As an owner of a Jelco SA-750D, I'm curious:

What are the pros & cons of knife edge bearing tonearms?
Depending on how they are designed, knife edge bearings can be fantastic.
Absolutely no "play" or tendency to vibrate.
It's nothing new of course, because the 1962ish Zenith "MicroTouch" belt drive record changer used them, and was able to track at unheard of low forces back then.

billshurv
broken record
Posts: 1775
Joined: 16 Oct 2014 15:38

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by billshurv » 04 Jun 2018 13:03

con: easy to damage in transport.

watchnerd
senior member
senior member
Posts: 531
Joined: 11 May 2014 19:09
Location: Seattle

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by watchnerd » 04 Jun 2018 14:35

Spinner45 wrote:
watchnerd wrote:The new TK series of Jelco tonearms (TK-950, TK-850) use knife-edge bearings, a departure from the ball bearings used in the SA-750 and its replacement, the TS-550.

As an owner of a Jelco SA-750D, I'm curious:

What are the pros & cons of knife edge bearing tonearms?
Depending on how they are designed, knife edge bearings can be fantastic.
Absolutely no "play" or tendency to vibrate.
It's nothing new of course, because the 1962ish Zenith "MicroTouch" belt drive record changer used them, and was able to track at unheard of low forces back then.
Why aren't they used more commonly?

analogaudio
long player
long player
United States of America
Posts: 4653
Joined: 06 Feb 2007 23:58
Location: Monroe NY USA

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by analogaudio » 04 Jun 2018 18:15

In the hands of the careful user they can be fine however for the less careful the traditional closed bearing is more robust and less vulnerable to accidental disturbance.

A small amount of friction in the bearing can be a good thing, it provides some damping of the tonearm+cartridge subsonic resonance.

Spinner45
long player
long player
United States of America
Posts: 2303
Joined: 01 Mar 2017 18:21

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by Spinner45 » 04 Jun 2018 21:57

analogaudio wrote:In the hands of the careful user they can be fine however for the less careful the traditional closed bearing is more robust and less vulnerable to accidental disturbance.

A small amount of friction in the bearing can be a good thing
, it provides some damping of the tonearm+cartridge subsonic resonance.
Who said?
Damping via fluid is one thing, but mechanical (bearings) friction is a no-no.

nat
long player
long player
Posts: 3821
Joined: 07 Nov 2002 20:05

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by nat » 05 Jun 2018 00:31

It seems to me that the argument for knife edge bearings is related to the argument for unipivots - compared to the force acting downward on a bearing as a result of the mass of the arm and cartridge, the forces, in whatever direction they are directed, of any and all resonances must be much smaller. So, despite not being trapped, unipivots and knife edge bearings are functionally tighter than gimballed bearings, where the bottom bearing must support a significant amount of the downward force, which then must loosen the vertical bearings which must have some play in order to minimize friction.
Every choice in audio has some cost - unipivots have woggly behavior during cuing, which many people cannot abide, knife edges can be damaged, and gimball bearings can be loose, or alternately, so tight they can be damaged, or have high friction.

edradour
member
member
Posts: 76
Joined: 25 Feb 2018 13:35

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by edradour » 05 Jun 2018 00:44

I can live with a bit of cueing wobble - unipivot all the way for me!

watchnerd
senior member
senior member
Posts: 531
Joined: 11 May 2014 19:09
Location: Seattle

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by watchnerd » 05 Jun 2018 03:47

analogaudio wrote:In the hands of the careful user they can be fine however for the less careful the traditional closed bearing is more robust and less vulnerable to accidental disturbance.

A small amount of friction in the bearing can be a good thing, it provides some damping of the tonearm+cartridge subsonic resonance.
Does this imply that if I have a suspended floor, suspended turntable, and cats....that knife edge is a less good choice than bearings?

analogaudio
long player
long player
United States of America
Posts: 4653
Joined: 06 Feb 2007 23:58
Location: Monroe NY USA

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by analogaudio » 05 Jun 2018 20:11

Cats and turntables are sometimes an unhappy combination.

Suspended floors and turntables are not going to put the bearing under much stress.

It may be that some knife edge bearings include some sort of protective restraining mechanism however a simple unrestrained knife edge requires very careful handing.

analogaudio
long player
long player
United States of America
Posts: 4653
Joined: 06 Feb 2007 23:58
Location: Monroe NY USA

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by analogaudio » 05 Jun 2018 20:22

Spinner45 wrote:
analogaudio wrote:In the hands of the careful user they can be fine however for the less careful the traditional closed bearing is more robust and less vulnerable to accidental disturbance.

A small amount of friction in the bearing can be a good thing
, it provides some damping of the tonearm+cartridge subsonic resonance.
Who said?
Damping via fluid is one thing, but mechanical (bearings) friction is a no-no.
Both fluid damping and bearing friction are forms of resistance to motion (drag) which the arm must do work to overcome. Energy is removed from the system and converted to (a very small amount of) heat. Provided that the energy removal method does not interfere with the function of the arm (a small amount of bearing friction do not interfere with arm motion) it makes no difference how the energy is removed.

The behavior of the arm+cart combination is an example of harmonic motion under the sub-heading driven damped oscillator. The damping quantity can be varied and the result is a change in the amplitude, the frequency and the rate of decay of the resonant motion of the arm.

Spinner45
long player
long player
United States of America
Posts: 2303
Joined: 01 Mar 2017 18:21

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by Spinner45 » 05 Jun 2018 21:37

analogaudio wrote:
Spinner45 wrote:
analogaudio wrote:In the hands of the careful user they can be fine however for the less careful the traditional closed bearing is more robust and less vulnerable to accidental disturbance.

A small amount of friction in the bearing can be a good thing
, it provides some damping of the tonearm+cartridge subsonic resonance.
Who said?
Damping via fluid is one thing, but mechanical (bearings) friction is a no-no.
Both fluid damping and bearing friction are forms of resistance to motion (drag) which the arm must do work to overcome. Energy is removed from the system and converted to (a very small amount of) heat. Provided that the energy removal method does not interfere with the function of the arm (a small amount of bearing friction do not interfere with arm motion) it makes no difference how the energy is removed.

The behavior of the arm+cart combination is an example of harmonic motion under the sub-heading driven damped oscillator. The damping quantity can be varied and the result is a change in the amplitude, the frequency and the rate of decay of the resonant motion of the arm.
Wha wha wha?..... HUH???
You're pulling my arm!
Do you write the "merits" usually advertised on those snake oil sites? :shock:

nat
long player
long player
Posts: 3821
Joined: 07 Nov 2002 20:05

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by nat » 06 Jun 2018 02:09

Not sure why 'snake oil' needs to be introduced into the conversation. I'm not knowledgeable enough to evaluate all the description, but that doesn't mean it's BS. It may be right, or it may be wrong, but I think it's a good faith attempt to explain damping.

watchnerd
senior member
senior member
Posts: 531
Joined: 11 May 2014 19:09
Location: Seattle

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by watchnerd » 06 Jun 2018 05:58

A practical question for the academy:

If given the choice between:

a) Keeping my current Jelco SA-750D gimbal tonearm, with the ability to tune damping with its oil reservoir


or

b) A new Jelco SA-850S, with theoretically superior knife edge, but no ability to tune

which would you pick and why?

analogaudio
long player
long player
United States of America
Posts: 4653
Joined: 06 Feb 2007 23:58
Location: Monroe NY USA

Re: Knife Edge Bearing - Pros & Cons?

Post by analogaudio » 06 Jun 2018 19:26

Spinner, I disagree with your statement and explained the reason.

If there is a problem perhaps it is not with your arm being pulled or snake oil merits (whatever they are) but it may be with your understanding of the physics of tonearms. In an attempt to assist you I gave the categories for the behavior of an arm+cartridge, it is not difficult, and the topics are well documented online, however I cannot do for you the work of study.

Post Reply