by josephazannieri » 16 Mar 2009 05:30
Iain:
There is a quick way to determine if the dark Garrard headshell will work. Measure the distance between the flange where the headshell meets the arm and the line between the holes where the cartridge screws go into the head. Make the same measurement on both heads, and see if it is the same. If it is the same, then the headshell may work on both arms. Now compare the angle between the flange on the headshell and the head shell. If the angle and the measurement are both the same, then the headshells are interchangeable. But that dark one is sho'nuff ugly! White paint, maybe?
The GE cartridge may be an RPX 040 or an RPX 041. The RPX 040 has a 3 mil 78 RPM stylus and the 041 has an old fashioned 1 mil stylus, strictly for mono LP's. You can take a look with a magnifying glass and immediately tell the difference. Both cartridges have instructions here on Vinyl Engine. You will find the info you need right here. My memory is that the RPX tracks about 7 grams. You need to be careful of the loading of the GE cartridges. You can't just Y them out and plug them into a stereo amp. Improper loading will change the frequency response of the cartridge. If you get into the loading issue, it's easy to figure out. The RPX was the prececessor to the VR.
There are 2 styli for that M7D. There is the N3D which tracks about 3-5 grams, and the N21D which tracks about 2 1/2 grams. N21D styli are still available. I have an M7D just like yours with the flat pins. The N21D was the "hot setup" way back when, but it wasn't a great tracker. I thought the M44 was a better cartridge. It also does not have the output of the M44.
By the way, that N55E stylus tracks at way lower pressure than the N44E. About 2 grams, I think.
You say you scoured the TPA 12 off ebay. Did this mean that you acquired it? Great!
I think that your arm may be the later arm. This is because the stylus pressure setting with the little screw, as opposed to the thumbwheel, is also found on the TPA 10, which was the later, more highly adjustable arm. I had a 4HF which had a TPA 12 with a thumbwheel on it, and it would not track much below 4 or 5 grams. I tried a Shure M7D in it, and it would not work properly. Traded it for an Autoslim-P, which didn't look half as cool, but worked way better.
I am not sure what you mean when you say that the arm "floats" too much. I think what it does is that the spring in the arm lifts the arm off the turntable. If the cartridge has insufficient mass, tiny adjustments will make great changes in stylus pressure. It may be that the Shure cartridge is not heavy enough for that arm. You may have to add a little mass inside the headshell to get the arm to behave better and control more easily.
Anyway, glad to hear of more progress. If you want arm recommendations, I have 2 arms on my 301. One is a Thorens TP 13A off a TD 150AB The other is a Grace G-707. The Grace has the advantage of being able to take care of the additional height above the plate that the 301 has. Some other arms require a shim to get enough height to work with the 301. The Thorens has to be jacked up about 3/8 of an inch to work right. I have used the Thorens for many years, though, and it has worked fine. And the price was right. The Grace is flexible enough so that it can be made to fit without going through huge gyrations, though it was somewhat fiddly to get set up right.
Anyway, hope this is helpful.
Good luck from the old constructor.
Joe Z.